← Blog

Search Engine Ranking Factors 2019: What Google Confirmed and What SEOs Believed

2026-11-14 · IndexNowFast Team
Search Engine Ranking Factors 2019: What Google Confirmed and What SEOs Believed

Quick Answer

Search engine ranking factors 2019 discussions centered on content relevance, quality backlinks, query-related language, perceived expertise, and mobile usability. Google's announcements documented developments involving mobile-first indexing, broad core updates, and BERT. However, industry surveys measured professional opinions, not Google's private algorithm weights or a universal ranking formula.

Key Takeaways

  • Content relevance received the highest average perceived-importance score in SparkToro's 2019 survey: 8.52 out of 10.
  • Quality backlinks remained an important subject in SEO research, but correlation does not prove that an individual link causes a particular ranking improvement.
  • Google made mobile-first indexing the default for newly discovered websites beginning July 1, 2019.
  • Mobile page speed was already a ranking consideration following Google's 2018 Speed Update.
  • Google's August 2019 core-update guidance explained that ranking declines do not automatically indicate a penalty.
  • BERT arrived in Google Search in October 2019 to improve language understanding, particularly for complex queries.
  • Google did not publish a universal ranking-factor checklist with fixed percentages for every website or search query.

What SEO Professionals Considered Important in 2019

One of the most useful historical references is SparkToro's Google Ranking Factors 2019 survey.

It gathered responses from 1,584 SEO professionals between August 6 and August 27, 2019.

Participants evaluated 26 potential ranking inputs using a scale from zero to ten. They were asked to estimate how important different factors were to Google's organic search rankings.

Content relevance received an average score of 8.52 out of 10, making it the highest-rated consideration in the survey.

Other prominent considerations included:

  • The quality of websites linking to a page.
  • The quality and relevance of individual linking pages.
  • Words and phrases related to the search query.
  • Perceived expertise and trustworthiness.
  • Mobile friendliness.
  • Appropriate keyword usage.

These results provide a useful snapshot of what experienced SEO professionals believed in 2019. They also show why content quality and relevance were central to SEO discussions at the time.

There is an important limitation, however: the survey did not measure Google's internal ranking algorithm. Respondents provided informed professional opinions, not confidential algorithm data.

The 8.52 score therefore means that respondents considered content relevance highly important. It does not mean that Google assigned relevance an 85.2% algorithmic weight.

The survey was also conducted among an English-speaking professional audience recruited through channels including Twitter, LinkedIn, and email. It should not be treated as a representative survey of every SEO professional or search market worldwide.

What Google Actually Confirmed About Search in 2019

Several important Google announcements help explain the search environment during 2019. They are particularly useful because they provide contemporary evidence rather than relying entirely on retrospective SEO opinions.

Mobile-first indexing became the default for new websites

On May 28, 2019, Google announced that mobile-first indexing would become the default for new websites previously unknown to Google Search, beginning July 1, 2019.

Mobile-first indexing means Google primarily uses the mobile version of a website's content for crawling and indexing. It does not mean Google simply gives every mobile-friendly website a ranking advantage over every desktop-oriented competitor.

The distinction matters because indexing and ranking are different processes.

A page must be available for crawling and eligible for indexing before it can appear in Google's index. Its position in search results is a separate question involving relevance and other ranking considerations.

Google had introduced mobile-first indexing before 2019. The July 2019 announcement expanded its default application to newly discovered websites rather than introducing the concept for the first time.

Official source: Google's mobile-first indexing announcement.

Google explained how broad core updates work

On August 1, 2019, Google published guidance explaining its broad core updates.

These updates involve changes to Google's overall search systems. Their purpose is to improve how relevant and authoritative content is presented in search results.

One particularly important point concerned ranking declines.

Google explained that a page losing positions after a broad core update does not necessarily mean that it violated Google's guidelines or suffered a specific penalty.

For example, a page might move from position three to position seven even though its content has not changed. Other pages may simply become more relevant or useful for the query after Google's systems are updated.

This distinction challenges an oversimplified approach to SEO troubleshooting.

A ranking decline does not automatically mean that a website needs more backlinks, additional keywords, or a technical repair. The appropriate response is to examine the affected queries, competing pages, search intent, content quality, and available performance evidence before deciding what to change.

Official source: What site owners should know about Google's August 2019 core update.

Review rich-result eligibility changed in September

On September 16, 2019, Google announced changes to review rich-result eligibility.

The changes restricted certain self-serving review markup, including reviews associated with LocalBusiness and Organization pages.

Rich results are enhanced search listings that may display additional information, such as review details, when a page meets Google's eligibility requirements.

This was an important development for websites using structured data. However, eligibility for a review-rich presentation should not be confused with proof of a universal organic-ranking improvement.

A structured-data change can affect how a result qualifies for enhanced presentation without establishing that the underlying page receives a general ranking boost.

Official source: Making Review Rich Results more helpful.

BERT improved Google's understanding of search queries

On October 25, 2019, Google announced the use of BERT in Search.

BERT stands for Bidirectional Encoder Representations from Transformers. It is a language-processing model designed to help systems understand relationships between words in context.

Consider a search query that contains several connected words. Changing or overlooking one small word can alter the meaning of the entire request. Traditional keyword matching may not adequately capture those relationships.

BERT helped Google better interpret the context and meaning of more complex queries.

The important editorial lesson is that content should answer the reader's actual question rather than rely on mechanically repeating exact-match keywords.

However, BERT was not a separate website-quality score. Google did not introduce a BERT optimization switch or publish a special BERT ranking percentage for website owners.

Its significance was in improving language understanding within Search.

Official source: Understanding searches better than ever before.

Which Ranking Factors Had the Strongest Supporting Evidence?

The evidence from 2019 becomes easier to understand when professional opinions, Google's official statements, and observational studies are considered separately.

The following original evidence matrix summarizes what the historical evidence supports, what it cannot establish, and how readers should evaluate old SEO recommendations.

The 2019 Ranking Evidence Matrix

Factor or developmentWhat was known in 2019Evidence classificationWhat the evidence establishesWhat it does not establishHow to interpret an old recommendation
Content relevanceHighest average perceived-importance score in SparkToro's survey: 8.52/10INDUSTRY-OPINIONSEO professionals strongly valued relevanceAn exact Google algorithm weightTreat relevance as an important professional priority, not a disclosed percentage
Quality backlinksHighly regarded by SEO professionals and associated with rankings in observational researchINDUSTRY-OPINION; OBSERVATIONAL-RESEARCHLink-related measurements showed statistical associationsA guaranteed ranking gain from each backlinkEvaluate source quality, context, and relevance rather than link counts alone
Query-related languageProfessionals emphasized relevant words and phrases; BERT improved language understandingINDUSTRY-OPINION; GOOGLE-CONFIRMEDLanguage understanding was an important search developmentA mandatory keyword-density formulaEvaluate whether the page answers the meaning of the query
Expertise and trustImportant considerations in professional assessmentsINDUSTRY-OPINIONSEO professionals considered these qualities importantA single publicly disclosed expertise scoreLook for reliable evidence and useful, trustworthy information without inventing scores
Mobile-first indexingDefault for newly discovered websites from July 1, 2019GOOGLE-CONFIRMEDGoogle documented a change in its primary mobile indexing approachAutomatic ranking improvements for mobile pagesDistinguish indexing configuration from ranking performance
Mobile page speedGoogle's mobile Speed Update had already rolled out in 2018GOOGLE-CONFIRMEDVery slow mobile experiences could be affectedThat speed always outweighs relevancePreserve the correct 2018 timeline and the update's limited scope
Broad core updatesGoogle documented broad changes to its search systems in 2019GOOGLE-CONFIRMEDGoogle explained that broad system changes can affect rankingsA complete list of algorithm weights or penaltiesDo not automatically interpret ranking losses as penalties
BERTAnnounced October 25, 2019 to improve query understandingGOOGLE-CONFIRMEDGoogle introduced a language-understanding improvementA standalone website optimization scoreUnderstand its historical role without inventing a BERT-specific SEO tactic
Review rich resultsGoogle changed structured-data eligibility in September 2019GOOGLE-CONFIRMEDEligibility rules for enhanced review presentations changedA universal organic-ranking boostSeparate rich-result eligibility from general organic ranking

The classifications are important:

  • GOOGLE-CONFIRMED: Supported by a relevant public Google announcement or official documentation.
  • INDUSTRY-OPINION: Based on what SEO professionals believed or reported in a survey.
  • OBSERVATIONAL-RESEARCH: Based on measured relationships between variables, without necessarily demonstrating cause and effect.

This distinction prevents historical SEO opinions from being presented as confirmed algorithm specifications.

Content relevance and search intent

Content relevance was the clearest professional priority in SparkToro's survey.

A relevant page addresses the subject and purpose behind a search. For example, someone searching for a definition needs a clear explanation, while someone comparing products needs meaningful differences, specifications, and purchasing considerations.

Repeating a keyword does not automatically make a page relevant. The information must actually satisfy the reader's purpose.

Google's current explanation of how Search ranks results also describes relevance, quality, usability, context, and other considerations.

This is useful background, but current documentation should not be presented as a precise reconstruction of Google's 2019 algorithm.

Backlinks and website authority

Backlinks were another prominent subject in 2019 SEO discussions.

A backlink is a link from another website to a particular page. Links can help search engines discover content and provide information about relationships between websites and pages.

However, the number of links alone does not establish their value. Relevance, source quality, context, and other characteristics matter when evaluating a link profile.

A 2019 Perficient and Stone Temple study examined link-related measurements across 27,000 queries. It reported statistical relationships between rankings and several link measures, including metrics associated with Moz.

Source: 2019 Study on Link Ranking.

The study offers useful observational evidence that link-related measurements were associated with rankings. It does not establish that acquiring a particular number of backlinks will cause a specific position improvement.

There is another important distinction: Moz Domain Authority and Page Authority are third-party metrics. They are not publicly disclosed Google ranking scores.

Website owners should therefore avoid interpreting a third-party authority metric as though it were a direct measurement of Google's internal algorithm.

Mobile usability and page speed

Mobile usability and page performance were important SEO considerations during 2019, but their historical timelines should not be confused.

Google's mobile Speed Update was announced in January 2018, with rollout beginning July 9, 2018. Google said it primarily affected the slowest mobile experiences and a relatively small percentage of queries.

It also explained that highly relevant content could still rank despite being slow.

This is important because it demonstrates that page speed should not be treated as a universal ranking trump card.

Mobile-first indexing, meanwhile, concerned Google's primary version of website content for crawling and indexing. It was not simply another name for mobile friendliness or page speed.

Official source: Using Page Speed in Mobile Search.

Expertise, trust, and useful information

Expertise and trust were prominent in the 2019 professional survey.

These ideas matter because readers need information they can evaluate and rely on. A useful article should explain its subject accurately, identify important limitations, support material claims, and provide enough context for readers to make informed decisions.

However, the survey's treatment of expertise and trust does not establish a single measurable Google ranking factor called an expertise score.

A historical article should avoid turning broad quality concepts into invented technical signals.

Contemporaneous academic research also examined factors associated with improving Google search rank.

One relevant publication is Ziakis and colleagues' *Important Factors for Improving Google Search Rank*, published in Future Internet on January 30, 2019.

Source: Important Factors for Improving Google Search Rank.

It provides useful academic background for understanding the SEO environment of that period. Like other independent research, it should not be confused with access to Google's confidential algorithm.

Common Misconceptions About 2019 Google Ranking Factors

Several historical SEO claims become misleading when opinions, indexing changes, and ranking-system announcements are treated as interchangeable.

Misconception 1: Content relevance had an 85.2% Google ranking weight

The 8.52 score came from a professional opinion survey using a ten-point scale.

It was not a percentage supplied by Google. It does not mean that relevance represented 85.2% of the ranking algorithm.

Misconception 2: Mobile-first indexing started in 2019

Google had already introduced mobile-first indexing before 2019.

The July 1, 2019 milestone concerned making it the default for newly discovered websites previously unknown to Google Search.

Misconception 3: Every backlink improves rankings

A backlink is not an automatic ranking improvement.

Observational studies can identify relationships between links and rankings, but they cannot establish a guaranteed outcome for every individual link.

Misconception 4: A core-update ranking decline proves a penalty

Google's August 2019 guidance explicitly cautioned against that conclusion.

A ranking change may reflect how Google's systems evaluate the broader set of available pages. It does not automatically demonstrate a policy violation or a specific technical problem.

Misconception 5: BERT was a new keyword optimization technique

BERT improved Google's understanding of language and query context.

It was not a new keyword-density requirement or a separate score that publishers could directly increase through a particular optimization technique.

Misconception 6: Structured review data guaranteed better rankings

Google's September 2019 announcement addressed review-rich-result eligibility.

Eligibility for an enhanced search presentation is not proof of a general organic-ranking advantage.

How to Evaluate a 2019 SEO Ranking-Factor Checklist Today

If you are reviewing an old SEO report, strategy, or ranking-factor list, use the following process to separate reliable historical information from unsupported claims.

1. Identify the original source.

Check whether the claim came from Google, an industry survey, an academic publication, or an individual SEO opinion. These sources do not provide the same type of evidence.

2. Check the publication date.

A statement about Google's 2019 search environment should be supported by documentation from that period or clearly identified historical research. Do not automatically apply current documentation to earlier algorithm behavior.

3. Separate indexing from ranking.

A URL being discovered, crawled, or indexed does not establish that it will rank well. These are different stages of search visibility.

For example, the IndexNowFast Google Index Checker can help users review observed index status for public URLs. A non-indexed result is a starting point for investigation, not a complete diagnosis or an explanation of ranking performance.

4. Evaluate backlink claims carefully.

Ask whether a study measured actual ranking changes, reported a correlation, or simply surveyed professional opinions. Do not interpret a third-party authority metric as a confirmed Google score.

5. Check whether the recommendation still fits its original purpose.

A historical mobile-first indexing announcement, a BERT language-understanding development, and a backlink-correlation study address different problems. They should not be combined into one undifferentiated checklist.

6. Avoid promises about indexing or ranking.

Submitting a URL can support discovery workflows, but Google controls whether a page is ultimately included in its index and where it appears in search results.

For public backlink pages, the IndexNowFast Backlink Indexer provides a workflow for submitting eligible URLs and monitoring processing and optional Google-check results.

Submission is not a guarantee of indexing, ranking improvement, or permanent inclusion.

The most reliable way to interpret historical SEO advice is to preserve the original evidence and understand exactly what it measured.

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the most important Google ranking factors in 2019?

Content relevance, quality backlinks, query-related language, perceived expertise and trust, and mobile usability were among the most prominent considerations discussed by SEO professionals. Google's public announcements also documented mobile-first indexing, core updates, and BERT. No universal numerical ranking formula was published.

Did backlinks matter in 2019?

Yes. Backlinks were prominent in professional SEO assessments and observational research. However, their value could not be reduced to a guaranteed ranking improvement for every acquired link. Relevance and source quality remained important considerations.

Was mobile-first indexing a ranking factor in 2019?

Mobile-first indexing primarily describes how Google uses mobile content for crawling and indexing. Google made it the default for newly discovered websites beginning July 1, 2019. It should not be confused with a direct guarantee of higher rankings.

Did Google use BERT in 2019?

Yes. Google announced BERT's use in Search on October 25, 2019. It helped Google better understand relationships between words and the context of complex search queries.

Was page speed a Google ranking factor in 2019?

Mobile page speed was already a ranking consideration following Google's 2018 Speed Update. Google explained that the update primarily affected the slowest mobile experiences and a relatively small percentage of queries. Relevant content could still rank despite being slow.

Did Google publish exact ranking-factor weights in 2019?

No. Google did not publish a universal table assigning fixed percentages to individual ranking factors. Surveys and independent studies offered professional opinions or observational evidence, not Google's confidential algorithm weights.

Final Perspective: What the 2019 Evidence Really Tells Us

The search engine ranking factors discussed in 2019 reveal an important distinction between what SEO professionals believed and what Google publicly confirmed.

Content relevance, backlinks, query language, expertise, and mobile usability were prominent in professional assessments. Google's own announcements provided clearer evidence about mobile-first indexing, broad core updates, review-rich-result eligibility, and BERT.

The strongest historical interpretation does not depend on pretending that every factor had a known numerical weight. It depends on understanding the type, date, and limitations of each piece of evidence.

For anyone revisiting search engine ranking factors 2019, the practical lesson is straightforward: use historical surveys to understand industry thinking, Google's announcements to establish documented changes, and independent studies to examine observed relationships.

Keep those evidence types separate, and old SEO advice becomes much easier to evaluate accurately.

Sources

  1. SparkToro — Google Ranking Factors 2019: Opinions from 1,500+ Professional SEOs
  2. Google Search Central — What site owners should know about Google's August 2019 core update
  3. Google Search Central — Mobile-First Indexing by default for new domains
  4. Google — Understanding searches better than ever before
  5. Google Search Central — Using page speed in mobile search ranking
  6. Google Search Central — Making Review Rich Results more helpful
  7. Perficient/Stone Temple — Links as a Google Ranking Factor: A 2019 Study
  8. Ziakis et al. — Important Factors for Improving Google Search Rank
  9. Google — How Search Works: Ranking Results
  10. IndexNowFast — Google Index Checker
  11. IndexNowFast — Backlink Indexer
  12. IndexNowFast — Blog