← Blog

Google Nofollow Is a Hint 2019 Announcement: What Changed

2026-11-17 · IndexNowFast Team
Google Nofollow Is a Hint 2019 Announcement: What Changed

Quick Answer

The search phrase “google nofollow is a hint 2019 announcement” refers to Google's September 10, 2019 decision to treat rel="nofollow" as a hint rather than an absolute directive. The change applied to ranking immediately; crawling and indexing followed on March 1, 2020. Google also introduced rel="sponsored" and rel="ugc". It did not mean every nofollow link would pass ranking credit.

Key Takeaways

  • Google announced the change on September 10, 2019.
  • All three link attributes became ranking hints immediately.
  • Google introduced rel="sponsored" for paid links and rel="ugc" for user-generated links.
  • The separate crawling and indexing change took effect on March 1, 2020.
  • Existing nofollow links did not need to be updated.
  • A hint gives Google discretion; it does not guarantee ranking credit or crawling.
  • Use noindex, not nofollow, when the goal is to prevent an accessible page from appearing in Google Search.

What Did Google Announce on September 10, 2019?

On September 10, 2019, Google Search Central published an announcement titled Evolving nofollow — new ways to identify the nature of links.

The announcement changed how Google interpreted link qualification attributes.

Previously, publishers commonly used rel="nofollow" to indicate that a link should not be treated as an ordinary editorial endorsement or used to pass ranking credit.

Google moved toward a more flexible interpretation. Instead of treating nofollow as an absolute instruction, its systems would treat the attribute as a hint when deciding which links to consider or exclude within Search.

This distinction matters because a hint gives Google discretion. It can consider the information associated with a link without being obligated to follow it or count it as a conventional ranking signal.

Google explained that links provide information beyond endorsement. For example, their anchor text can help explain the subject of a destination page, while link patterns can provide information useful for identifying unnatural linking behavior.

The announcement also introduced two additional attributes: rel="sponsored" and rel="ugc".

These additions gave website owners a more precise way to describe why a link exists instead of relying on one attribute for several different situations.

Why Did Google Change Its Approach?

The traditional nofollow model was relatively broad. Publishers used it for advertising links, comments, forum posts, and links they did not want to endorse.

However, these situations are not identical.

A paid advertisement has a commercial relationship. A forum link comes from user-generated content. A link that a publisher simply does not want to endorse has another meaning.

Google's updated system provided separate labels for these relationships while retaining the flexibility to interpret link information across Search systems.

The important point is that Google did not abandon link qualification. It expanded the information available to its systems and changed how those qualifications could be interpreted.

The Two Important Dates: September 2019 and March 2020

One of the most frequently misunderstood parts of the announcement is its implementation timeline.

Google described two separate changes, affecting different Search functions.

DateFunction affectedWhat changedPractical meaning
September 10, 2019RankingAll three link attributes became hints for ranking purposes immediatelyGoogle could use discretion when interpreting qualified links for ranking systems.
March 1, 2020Crawling and indexingNofollow became a hint for crawling and indexing purposes as wellGoogle could consider nofollow links as potential discovery information rather than treating the attribute as an absolute restriction.

September 10, 2019: Ranking Treatment Changed Immediately

Google stated that all three link attributes would work as ranking hints from the announcement date.

This was the first stage of the change.

A website owner did not need to wait until 2020 for the new ranking treatment to begin. Google's announcement made that part effective immediately.

However, the change did not guarantee that nofollow links would contribute ranking credit. Google retained discretion over how its systems interpreted individual links.

March 1, 2020: Crawling and Indexing Treatment Changed

The second stage arrived on March 1, 2020.

From this date, Google also began treating nofollow as a hint for crawling and indexing purposes.

This distinction is important because crawling, indexing, and ranking are different processes.

  • Crawling: A search engine retrieves a page to examine its content and links.
  • Indexing: A search engine processes information about a page and decides whether it should be included in its index.
  • Ranking: A search engine determines how relevant and useful a page is for a particular search and where it may appear.

A link can provide discovery information without automatically becoming a ranking endorsement. Likewise, a crawling decision does not guarantee that a destination will enter Google's index.

Google's original September 2019 announcement explicitly distinguishes the immediate ranking change from the March 2020 crawling and indexing change.

Contemporary coverage also documented the transition. See Search Engine Land's September 2019 announcement coverage and Search Engine Journal's February 2020 report.

What Do Nofollow, Sponsored, and UGC Mean?

Google's announcement introduced two new link attributes while retaining nofollow. Each describes a different relationship between the publisher and the destination.

1. rel="nofollow"

Nofollow identifies a link that the publisher does not want to qualify as an ordinary endorsement or association.

For example:

``html <a href="https://example.com/website/" rel="nofollow"> External resource </a> ``

A publisher might use this attribute when linking to a source they do not wish to endorse or associate their site with.

Nofollow remains useful, but it should not be treated as an absolute command that prevents Google from discovering or considering a destination.

2. rel="sponsored"

Google introduced sponsored for advertising, sponsorships, and other compensation-related arrangements.

Example:

``html <a href="https://example.com/product/" rel="sponsored"> Sponsored product </a> ``

If a publisher receives payment, compensation, or another commercial benefit in exchange for a placement, sponsored is Google's preferred qualification.

Google's current guidance also accepts nofollow for paid links, although sponsored is the more descriptive choice.

3. rel="ugc"

UGC means user-generated content.

Google recommends this attribute for links contributed by users rather than editorially selected by the website owner.

Typical examples include:

  • Blog comments.
  • Discussion forums.
  • Community posts.
  • User-submitted content containing external links.

Example:

``html <a href="https://example.com/resource/" rel="ugc"> Community recommendation </a> ``

UGC does not automatically mean a link is harmful or spam. It identifies the origin of the link so Google can interpret its context.

Can You Combine These Attributes?

Yes. Google supports multiple values in one rel attribute.

For example:

``html <a href="https://example.com/resource/" rel="ugc nofollow"> Community resource </a> ``

A commercial link submitted through user-generated content might use:

``html <a href="https://example.com/product/" rel="ugc sponsored"> Community-sponsored product </a> ``

The appropriate combination depends on the actual relationship represented by the link. There is no need to add every attribute to every external link.

For current implementation details, consult Google's documentation: Qualify your outbound links to Google.

Does Google Follow Nofollow Links or Pass Ranking Credit?

Not automatically.

This is probably the most important misconception to correct when interpreting Google's 2019 announcement.

Google changed nofollow from an absolute directive to a hint. That gives its systems flexibility, but it does not promise that every nofollow link will be followed, counted, or used to improve a destination's rankings.

There are three separate ideas worth understanding.

1. Google can interpret link information.

A link can provide useful context through its anchor text, destination, and surrounding content. Google explained that these signals can be informative even when a link is qualified.

2. A hint does not guarantee a particular outcome.

Google can decide how to use the information. The presence of rel="nofollow" does not establish that the link will pass PageRank or another specific ranking benefit.

3. Google does not publish the individual weighting of these links.

There is no publicly verified percentage of ranking credit that can be assigned to nofollow links. Claims such as a fixed amount of PageRank passing through every nofollow link are unsupported.

Google's current documentation says links carrying these qualification attributes will generally not be followed, although their destinations may still be discovered through other sources, including sitemaps and other links.

Consequently, two statements should not be confused:

  • Google may consider information associated with a nofollow link.
  • Every nofollow link automatically passes ranking credit.

The first is consistent with the hint model. The second is not established by Google's announcement.

For additional historical context, Search Engine Land's September 12, 2019 industry reaction discusses the questions SEO professionals raised after the announcement.

Nofollow vs. Noindex: What Is the Difference?

Nofollow and noindex sound similar, but they solve different problems.

The distinction is between qualifying an individual link and controlling whether a page should appear in search results.

Featurerel="nofollow"noindex
Applies toAn individual linkAn entire page
Main purposeQualifies the relationship with a linked destinationRequests that a page not be included in search results
Controls page indexing?NoYes, when Google can crawl and process the directive
Suitable for preventing a page from appearing in Search?NoYes
Can Google discover a destination through other sources?YesNot the purpose of the directive

What Does Nofollow Actually Control?

Consider a blog article that links to an external website.

The publisher may add rel="nofollow" because they do not want to imply endorsement of that destination.

This qualification applies to the link. It does not automatically instruct Google to exclude the destination page from its index.

The destination might still be discovered through another website, an XML sitemap, or another available discovery method.

What Does Noindex Control?

A noindex directive is used when a website owner wants an accessible page excluded from search results.

For example, a page can contain this HTML directive:

``html <meta name="robots" content="noindex"> ``

Google must be able to crawl the page to discover and process the noindex directive.

Blocking the page in robots.txt can prevent Google from retrieving its contents and seeing that directive. Therefore, robots.txt disallow is not a reliable replacement for noindex when the objective is to keep a page out of Google's index.

Google explains this in its official guide, Block Search Indexing with noindex.

How Can You Check Whether a Page Is Indexed?

If you own the website, Google Search Console's URL Inspection tool can help you examine Google's indexed information and run a separate Live Test of the current page.

The two views answer different questions:

  • The indexed information describes what Google currently knows about the URL in its index.
  • The Live Test examines the page's current accessibility and technical eligibility.

You can follow the practical Google Search Console URL Inspection Tool guide for additional troubleshooting guidance.

For checking multiple public URLs, the Google Index Checker provides bulk status checking and CSV export.

Remember that an index-status result is a point-in-time observation, not a permanent guarantee of inclusion or exclusion.

The important lesson is simple: checking indexing status, qualifying a link, and preventing page indexing are three different tasks.

Which Link Attribute Should You Use Today?

The best attribute depends on why the link exists. Google's current outbound-link documentation provides the following practical distinctions.

SituationRecommended treatmentWhy
Ordinary editorial linkNo qualification normally neededA genuine editorial link does not automatically require a rel attribute.
Paid placement or advertisementrel="sponsored"Identifies the commercial relationship.
Paid placement where nofollow is usedrel="nofollow" is acceptableGoogle continues to accept nofollow for paid links.
Blog comment or forum linkrel="ugc"Identifies user-generated content.
Link without intended endorsement or associationrel="nofollow"Communicates the publisher's qualification preference.
Page that must not appear in Google SearchMeta robots noindexControls page-level indexing rather than an individual link.

A Practical Example for Website Owners

Imagine that a website publishes three different types of external links.

Example A: An editorial reference

An article links to an independently selected research resource because it helps readers understand the subject. The publisher normally does not need to add a qualification attribute simply because the link is external.

Example B: A paid product placement

A company pays the publisher to feature a product. The link should use rel="sponsored" to identify the commercial relationship.

Example C: A reader-submitted forum link

A community member posts a useful external resource in a discussion. The website can use rel="ugc" to identify the link as user-generated content.

These examples show why the three attributes should not be treated as interchangeable labels.

Does the 2019 Announcement Change Paid-Link Requirements?

No. The announcement did not remove Google's expectations for properly qualifying commercial links.

Google subsequently reiterated its guidance in A reminder on qualifying links and our link spam update, published July 26, 2021.

The practical approach remains to identify the relationship accurately. Use sponsored for paid placements, UGC for contributed links, and nofollow where the publisher does not want to imply endorsement or association.

Changing a link to nofollow does not make an otherwise manipulative link scheme automatically compliant with Google's policies.

Do Existing Nofollow Links Need to Be Changed?

No.

Google explicitly stated in its September 2019 announcement that website owners did not need to change existing nofollow links.

There was no requirement to revisit every historical link and replace its attribute simply because Google adopted the hint model.

However, reviewing existing link markup can still be useful when the original attribute does not accurately describe the relationship.

For example:

  • An old paid placement using nofollow can remain valid, although sponsored is now the preferred, more descriptive option.
  • A user-generated forum link can use ugc.
  • A link that the publisher does not wish to endorse can continue using nofollow.

The objective should be accurate link qualification, not unnecessary mass editing.

If you manage a large website, prioritize commercial links, user-generated sections, and templates that generate external links automatically.

There is no evidence-based reason to change every existing nofollow attribute solely to pursue an assumed ranking benefit.

Frequently Asked Questions

When did Google announce that nofollow was a hint?

Google announced the change on September 10, 2019. The ranking treatment changed immediately.

When did Google start treating nofollow as a crawling and indexing hint?

The separate crawling and indexing change took effect on March 1, 2020.

Does a nofollow link automatically pass PageRank?

No. The hint model gives Google discretion, but it does not guarantee that a particular nofollow link passes PageRank or improves rankings.

Does Google always ignore nofollow links?

No. Google can consider information associated with qualified links. However, that does not mean it will follow every such link or use it as a ranking signal.

Should I change old nofollow links to sponsored?

Not automatically. Google said existing nofollow links did not need to be changed. Sponsored is the preferred qualification for paid placements going forward.

Is nofollow the same as noindex?

No. Nofollow qualifies an individual link. Noindex is a page-level directive used to prevent an accessible page from appearing in search results.

Should forum links use nofollow or ugc?

Google recommends ugc for user-generated links, including forum posts and comments. Nofollow can also be combined with ugc when appropriate.

Can a nofollow link help Google discover a page?

Google's hint model allows it to consider qualified links for discovery purposes, but a nofollow link is not a guarantee that Google will crawl the destination. The page may also be discovered through other links or a sitemap.

Does the 2019 announcement mean nofollow backlinks are now ranking backlinks?

Not as a general rule. The announcement changed Google's treatment from a strict directive to a hint. It did not establish that every nofollow backlink receives ranking credit.

Final Thoughts

Google's September 10, 2019 nofollow announcement was an important change in how Search interpreted qualified links. It introduced a more flexible hint model, added sponsored and UGC classifications, and later extended the crawling and indexing treatment on March 1, 2020.

The most useful way to understand the change is to remember its two separate dates and its practical limits.

A nofollow link is not automatically a ranking vote, and it is not a reliable way to prevent a destination from entering Google's index.

For website owners and SEO professionals, the right approach is to describe link relationships accurately, use sponsored for commercial placements, identify user-generated links with UGC, and reserve nofollow for links that should not imply endorsement or association.

When a page itself must stay out of search results, use an appropriate noindex directive instead.

The original announcement changed how Google could interpret link qualifications. It did not remove the need for accurate markup, sound technical SEO, or realistic expectations about crawling, indexing, and rankings.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central — Evolving nofollow: New ways to identify the nature of links (September 10, 2019)
  2. Google Search Central — Qualify your outbound links to Google
  3. Google Search Central — Block Search Indexing with noindex
  4. Google Search Central — A reminder on qualifying links and our link spam update (July 26, 2021)
  5. Search Engine Land — Google to treat nofollow link attribute as a hint (September 10, 2019)
  6. Search Engine Land — What really matters in Google's nofollow changes? SEOs ask (September 12, 2019)
  7. Search Engine Journal — Google Crawl and Indexing Update March 1, 2020

---